OH GOD I know what you're talking about. I don't know if you've seen some of my more recent fic (my narniaexchange and some England!fic) but when I posted the England!fic over at FF.net the first thing I got was backlash for being OOC (because Peter wasn't a perfect gentleman and because Lucy was angry). And while at the same time I enjoy some of the book canon, it's inconsistent and unrealistic, and with the movies there's just a greater reality and depth.

I don't even want to post my narniaexchange over at FF.net for fear of what the book canon elitists will think. :/